Accessible brand colors: can people actually read yours?

Accessibility in branding starts with contrast. The WCAG ratios to aim for, real color pairs from Mosaic and two other brands that pass or fail, and do's and don'ts.

The short answer

Text needs enough contrast with the color behind it. WCAG asks for at least 4.5 to 1 for regular text and 3 to 1 for large headings.

A brand guide lists which of your colors pass together, so nobody has to test each post.

Takeaways

  • Contrast is measured as a ratio, from 1:1 (none) to 21:1 (black on white).
  • Aim for 4.5:1 for body text and 3:1 for large headlines.
  • Pale pastels and mid-tone pairs fail most often.
  • A guide that prints the passing and failing pairs saves the check every time.

This is a post about accessibility: whether people can read the words you set in your brand colors, including people with low vision or color blindness and anyone reading on a phone in the sun. It comes down to one number, contrast.

A palette can look lovely on a mood board and still fail the first time someone sets a sentence in it. Soft blush text on cream, white on a sunny yellow, sage on a slightly darker sage. The colors belong together. You just can't read them.

What is color contrast?

Contrast is how different two colors are in lightness. It's measured as a ratio. Black text on white is 21 to 1, the most you can get. The same color on itself is 1 to 1, which means invisible.

Hue doesn't count for much here. A red and a green of the same lightness can look loud together and still be hard to read, and that pair is the one most people with color blindness can't separate at all.

How much contrast is enough?

The Web Content Accessibility Guidelines, WCAG, set the numbers most designers work to:

WCAG contrast minimums
TextLevel AALevel AAA
Regular text4.5 : 17 : 1
Large text (about 24px, or 19px bold)3 : 14.5 : 1
Icons and graphic parts3 : 1No higher level

AA is the usual target. It's the level most accessibility laws point to, and a sensible floor for anything with words on it.

What does this look like in a real palette?

Mosaic has eight colors: navy, lavender, sky, cyan, mint, teal, yellow and grey. Every one of them looks fine on a swatch card. The question is which text can sit on which.

Mosaic's color palette page: Navy #2F5672, Lavender #8393C9, Sky #7EB1DE, Cyan #7CD1ED, Mint #96D1B4, Teal #51B9B6, Yellow #EDCC3E and Grey #E8E7E7, each with its CMYK values
Mosaic's eight colors, with HEX and CMYK, from its brand guide.

Here are the ratios, worked out from those HEX codes against white and against the palette's own dark navy, #11202C:

  • Aa3.0 : 1

    Fails: White on Lavender

  • Aa5.5 : 1

    Passes: Dark navy on Lavender

  • Aa2.3 : 1

    Fails: White on Sky

  • Aa7.3 : 1

    Passes: Dark navy on Sky

  • Aa1.6 : 1

    Fails: White on Yellow

  • Aa4.9 : 1

    Passes: Navy on Yellow

  • Aa2.3 : 1

    Fails: White on Teal

  • Aa7.1 : 1

    Passes: Dark navy on Teal

Mosaic's colors with white text and with dark navy text. Regular text needs 4.5 : 1.

The pattern is the one in the list further down: the light and mid colors are grounds, and the dark ones carry the words. White works on exactly one of Mosaic's colors, the navy at 7.8 : 1. That's why the brand guide prints the pass and fail pairs on the page, with a green tick and a red cross, so whoever makes the next flyer doesn't have to run a checker.

Do's and don'ts from three brands

The same test on other palettes. In each, the colors are the brand's own.

  • Aa7.5 : 1

    Passes: Israel Home Store: white on Deep Navy

  • Aa1.9 : 1

    Fails: Israel Home Store: white on Golden Sunrise

  • Aa3.9 : 1

    Fails: Israel Home Store: Deep Navy on Golden Sunrise, large text only

  • Aa2.6 : 1

    Fails: Israel Home Store: white on Blush Pink

  • Aa5.3 : 1

    Passes: Tri-State Surgical: white on Trust Blue

  • Aa5.3 : 1

    Passes: Tri-State Surgical: Caring Navy on Healing Sand

  • Aa2.4 : 1

    Fails: Tri-State Surgical: white on Healing Sand

  • Aa4.5 : 1

    Passes: Mosaic: Navy on Cyan, just clears it

Three brands, one rule: check the text color against the ground.
  • Do put the brand's darkest color on its lighter ones. Caring Navy on Healing Sand is 5.3 : 1, and Mosaic's dark navy reaches 5.5 : 1 or better on Lavender, Sky and Teal.
  • Do use the big, bright colors as bands, blocks and backgrounds. Sunrise yellow and blush pink are good at getting seen.
  • Don't put white text on a bright accent because it feels crisp. White on yellow, orange or pink fails in all three palettes.
  • Don't treat a pass at 3 : 1 as a pass for body text. Deep Navy on Golden Sunrise is fine for a headline and wrong for a paragraph.

Logos have their own do's and don'ts, and Mosaic's guide puts them on one page.

Mosaic's do's and don'ts page, 'Break the rules. Not the logo.': don't recolor the mark outside the approved palette, don't stretch, crop, rotate or add effects, don't place low-contrast lockups on light backgrounds, don't rebuild the wordmark in another typeface
Mosaic's do's and don'ts: the contrast rule applies to the logo too. The bottom-left lockup is the low-contrast one.

Why does this matter off the web?

The guidelines were written for websites, but the problem is the same everywhere. A post gets read on a phone at half brightness on a bus. A flyer gets read from across a room. A slide gets projected onto a washed-out screen. Every one of those drops the contrast you designed with, so a pair that barely passed on your monitor won't pass there.

Then there's the audience. Plenty of people read with low vision, color blindness or just tired eyes, and none of them tell you they skipped the post.

Which color pairs fail most often?

  • Pastel on white. Blush, mint and lavender text on a white ground rarely reach 3:1.
  • White on bright yellow or light orange. Yellow is very light even when it's saturated.
  • Two mid-tones. A medium teal on a medium coral looks bold and reads badly.
  • Gray body text. Light gray paragraphs look neat and fail quickly.

None of this means the brand can't use pale colors. It means pale colors go behind dark text rather than into the text itself.

How does a brand guide handle this?

In the brand guide that comes with every Brand Kit, every text-on-color pair in the palette is checked against WCAG AA. The guide prints the approved pairs next to the failing ones, so nobody has to remember which is which. When a palette has light and dark tints of each color, the dark ones usually carry text and the light ones become grounds.

A four-color palette might end up with eight approved pairings: each color as a background under two of the others. That's the whole list, and anyone making a post can pick from it without running a checker.

What if my favorite color fails?

Keep it, and give it a different job. It can be a background, a band across a photo, an icon fill or a highlight behind a word. Darken it slightly to make a text version that passes, and list both in the guide. How many brand colors you need covers how tints like that fit into a palette.

Questions people also ask

WCAG level AA asks for at least 4.5 to 1 for normal text and 3 to 1 for large text, which is roughly 24px regular or 19px bold and up. Level AAA asks for 7 to 1 and 4.5 to 1.

Written byVic Ulsh, brand and logo designer in Tel Aviv. 20+ years in design, 10+ in branding. More about me